Shame and the Stories We Tell Ourselves: How Therapy Helps You Rewrite the Narrative
Shame is one of the most universal human experiences and one of the least discussed, partly because the nature of shame is to keep itself hidden. Unlike guilt, which says “I did something bad,” shame says “I am something bad,” and the person carrying it tends to assume, with remarkable consistency, that if others knew the truth of what was inside them they would be rejected, abandoned, or confirmed in their worst fear: that they are fundamentally deficient as a human being. Most people who carry significant shame have lived with it for so long that it no longer announces itself as shame. It has simply become the water they swim in, the quiet assumption beneath every interaction that they need to perform better, hide more carefully, or work harder to justify their presence. As a therapist serving individuals and families in Hidden Hills and Calabasas for over forty years, I have rarely met a person in genuine psychological distress for whom shame was not somewhere near the center of the picture.
Where Shame Comes From
Shame is a relational wound. It almost always originates in the context of a relationship, typically an early one, where a child received the message that something about them, their needs, their emotions, their body, their mistakes, or their very presence, was unacceptable or burdensome. This message is rarely delivered directly. It comes through tone, through withdrawal, through criticism, through comparison to a sibling, through the consistent absence of delight in who the child is rather than what the child does. Children are not equipped to say “that is my parent’s limitation.” They are equipped to conclude “there is something wrong with me,” and to organize their behavior accordingly.
Shame also develops through experiences of humiliation, failure, or exposure in social contexts, particularly during adolescence when the need for belonging is most acute and the consequences of being seen as different or lesser feel most catastrophic. A single memorable incident of public embarrassment can plant a shame response that shapes how a person moves through the world for decades afterward.
How Shame Organizes a Life
Once established, shame becomes an organizing principle. The person develops strategies to prevent exposure: overachievement to prove they are worthy, perfectionism to ensure there is nothing to be criticized, people-pleasing to keep others approving, withdrawal from situations where they might be seen and found wanting. These strategies are exhausting, and they are also self-reinforcing. The person who hides never discovers that they would have been accepted. The person who overachieves never discovers that their worth does not depend on their output. The shame persists because the behaviors that would disprove it are precisely the behaviors the shame makes impossible.
Shame also does significant damage to relationships. Intimacy requires vulnerability, and vulnerability requires the willingness to be known, which shame makes genuinely threatening. People carrying deep shame often find that as relationships move toward genuine closeness, something in them pulls back, deflects, or provokes conflict as an unconscious way of creating distance before the other person can discover what they are afraid is there. The result is a life in which the connection that would most help is consistently kept at arm’s length.
Why Shame Requires Relational Healing
Research on shame, much of it developed by Brene Brown building on decades of prior clinical literature, confirms what experienced therapists have long understood: shame cannot be healed in isolation. The experience of bringing something shameful into a relationship and finding that it is received without rejection is not merely comforting. It is neurologically corrective. It begins to update the belief system at the level where the belief actually lives.
This is why the therapeutic relationship is particularly valuable for shame work. The consistent experience of being known by someone who is neither impressed by your performance nor disturbed by your failures, who maintains genuine regard across the full range of what you bring into the room, is one of the most powerful counters to shame that exists. It does not happen in a single session, and it requires a willingness to bring the shameful material into the room rather than presenting only the curated version. That willingness is itself an act of courage, and it tends to build on itself. What began as terrifying becomes, over time, simply honest. And honesty, at that level, is among the most relief-producing experiences I witness in my work.
What Changes When Shame Loosens Its Hold
People who do sustained work on shame consistently describe a similar set of changes, not dramatic transformations but a quieter shift in how daily life is experienced. Less energy spent managing impressions and more available for genuine presence. A reduced compulsion to overwork or over-explain or preemptively apologize. The capacity to make a mistake without it becoming evidence of fundamental inadequacy. Relationships that feel less like performances and more like genuine contact. And underneath all of it, a kind of quiet that many people describe as the first real rest they have known in a very long time.
Susie Cole Rome, MA, LMFT, is a licensed marriage and family therapist with over forty years of experience providing therapy for individuals, couples, and families in Hidden Hills, Calabasas, and across the Greater Los Angeles area, in person and via secure telehealth for California residents.
Ready to Begin?
Susie Cole Rome, MA, LMFT, offers compassionate therapy for individuals, couples, and families in Hidden Hills, Calabasas, Woodland Hills, Malibu, Agoura Hills, and throughout the Greater Los Angeles area, with secure telehealth available for all California residents.
📞 (818) 618-4762
✉️ Susie@susierome.com
📍 24933 Kit Carson Rd, Hidden Hills, CA 91302
👉 Schedule a Free 15-Minute Consultation